Collaborative Green Infrastructure Design Group C: Difference between revisions

From Wikienfk5
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(Created page with "---> back to group page working group C '''''Please add the title of your case study here, adjust the map coordinates and repl...")
 
No edit summary
Line 1: Line 1:
---> back to group page [[Green Infrastructure 2014 - Working Group C|working group C]]
---> back to group page [[Green Infrastructure 2014 - Working Group C|working group C]]


'''''Please add the title of your case study here, adjust the map coordinates and replace the moa image with a characteristic image of your site'''''
'''''
Green/Blue Infrastructure of the urban area of the river of Tirana, ALBANIA
'''''




{| align="right" width="300pt" style="background:Gainsboro; color:black"
{| align="right" width="300pt" style="background:Gainsboro; color:black"
|-  
|-  
| '''Name''' ||style="background:Lavender"| '' add name''
| '''Name''' ||style="background:Lavender"| '' Green/blue infrastructure in north of Tirana''
|-
|-
| '''Location''' || style="background:Lavender"|''add location''
| '''Country''' ||style="background:Lavender"| '' Albania''
|-
|-
| '''Country''' || style="background:Lavender"|''add country''
| '''City''' || style="background:Lavender"|''Tirana''
|-
|-
| '''Authors''' || style="background:Lavender"|''add author''
| '''Authors''' || style="background:Lavender"|''Mirsa Gishti''
|-
|-
| colspan="3" align="center" style="background:silver"| [[Image:Moa.jpg|300px]]
| colspan="3" align="center" style="background:silver"|[[File:River of Tirana.jpg|400px]]
|-  
|-  
|  ||style="background:Lavender"|  
|  ||style="background:Lavender"|  
|-  
|-  
| colspan="3" align="center" style="background:silver"| {{#widget:GoogleMaps
| colspan="3" align="center" style="background:silver"|{{#widget:GoogleMaps
|width=300
|width=400
|height=200
|height=200
|lat=71.295556
|lat=41.35058978679405
|lng=-156.766389
|lng=19.803779075305215
|zoom=8
|zoom=13
|centermarker=yes
|centermarker=yes
|maptypecontrol=yes
|maptypecontrol=yes
Line 31: Line 33:
}}
}}
|}
|}
 
== Rationale: Blue/green infrstructure-connecting the historic centre with the national park ==
 
''The river of Tirana is located between the historic centre and the National Park of the Paskuqani in northern part of the city. It is one of the 5 developing poles of the multicentric masterplan of the city approved in 2012. The population is expeted to increase during the next years, according to the demographic data and this fact makes the river`s zone a potential area of high density and multifunctionality in the future. The landscape is shaped mostly by natural and seminatural features like hills, the river and the park.  Currently informal buildings, waste pollution and low mantainance of ecologic environment has become a very big problem to solve. It is an emergency to approach the future development of the area based on a well integrated green/blue infrastructure project since nothing has been done in this aspect and planning is always a better choice than improving when is too late.''
 
== Author's perspective ==
''
 
I have a master degree in urban planning and a background in architecture. The area of the study case is located in the city where I have spent 12 years living. Beside that, my master thesis project was near the river of Tirana´s zone but my approach was focused on the southern part of it and on the new residential buildings proposal.''
 
== Landscape and/or urban context of your case ==
== Landscape and/or urban context of your case ==
*''Biogeography, cultural features, overall character, history and dynamics''
* you can keep this short
* Illustration: Map; sketches; short descriptive analyses


== What are the overall objectives of your design? What are the specific objectives for enhancing green infrastrucutre? ==
*''Biogeography, cultural features, overall character, history and dynamics
 


''Please give a short written argumentation (not more than 150 words). It is ok if you have different or even contradicting objectives within your group. Just make it explicit at the beginning of your process ''
''' Overview of the city '''
 
Tirana, the capital of Albania, is situated 40
kilometers from Durres, the largest port in the
country and 26 km from Mother Theresa
International Airport. It is the largest city, with an
increasing population, with an average annual
growth rate of 3.77% from 2001–2009 (INSTAT,
2009). The faster urbanization influences the city's
development, the living environment and the socioeconomic
situation.Tirana has the opportunity to be regenerated
itself after a long term of isolation.
Exists a lot of informality in the northpart of the city,
but this informality is supposed to be the shelter for
those persons who live there. 
 
 
 
[[Image:Historical evolution.jpg|right|430px|]]
 
----
 
 
'''Biogeography of the area'''
 
Tirana‟s contact with water is concretized in two
lakes (one in north and the other in south) and two
rivers (Tirana River and Lana River) that run parallel
to each other, between the two lakes. The actual
condition of the Tirana River waterfront is weak and
the regeneration of it is an important issue for the
development of the city.
 
 
 
Its north-south axis, which eventually corresponds
to the main boulevard of the city, serves as a
connector between the lakes and the rivers.
Existing general land use of the area
under study and identification of the water surfaces
of Tirana city. (Source: GrimShaw analysis and Dar
analysis for Tirana Masterplan 2012)
“Tirana in the XVI century was defined by a
building mosque, a hammam and a bakery,” (Aliaj,
Myftiu & Lulo, 2003). So, water was not the most
important factor in the foundation of the city, but it
was one of the natural resources affecting the
growth of its early settlements and melding its
future. In the actual situation, there do exist a close
relationship between the water and the city.
Like other natural elements (Dajti Mountain, hills,
agriculture etc.) water influences the urban
development and the stratum of the urban fabric.
 
The urbanization process happens on
both sides of the Lana and Tirana River, around
lakes. Tirana‟s green regions are strengthened by
the topography besieging the urban superficies, the
streets, the habitation areas etc. The source of Tirana River is in the mountains to
the east. It flows to west through the northern area
of the city. In the mountains, it flows through the
protected area of Dajti Mountain, providing an
ecological corridor, through which wildlife can
extend and survive. Its estuary is 30-40 km to the
north-west at Rodon Bay, on the Adriatic coast. The
topography of Tirana from east to west is
nearly 1% slope. The existing natural movement
results fast during periods of rainfall, which
combined with coarse sand and cobbles by the
mountains located close, becomes a destructive
force.
 
----
 
 
After the centralized society dropped to the market
economy in the ‟90s, Tirana, as many other postsocialist
cities of Europe, experienced an extensive
growth by the congestion of the new population that
settled in the periphery of it, which was not well
incorporated into the urban life of the city.
This decentralized action induced spontaneous
settlement by the citizens, with their own resources,
the same as it did in different places of the world,
including Bogota, Bombay, Caracas etc., which
suffer from a high percentage of informality. In
Tirana, the social and spatial pattern viewpoint of
the phenomena is little investigated.
 
 
----
 
The informal settlements (Kamza, Bathore and
Paskuqan, the three major informal housing
settlements around Tirana, with over 90% of the
dwellings constructed illegally), grew mainly in the
early 2000, in suspicious and poor conditions. This
gave birth to an “informal city”, which was not
acknowledged by the authorities, a self-made
structure by rural immigrants which saw Tirana as a
better opportunity for their familiar and future life.
This city grew without planning control, creating a
spatial and cultural disconnection with the existing
urban situation. The consolidation of the “selfadding-
process” raises the problems of social injury
which needs to be resolved. The sustainable
development of these areas, the integration and
consolidation need a better understanding of these
problems, to go to the final solutions. “The
segregation involves spatial separation of
population groups and spatial separation reduces
interaction among groups over space” (Newby,
1982).
 
----
 
'''The existing condition of the Tirana river waterfront'''
One of these informal areas is that of the North
Tirana (Tirana River area near Paskuqan). The
current ecological situation of the urban Tirana River
demonstrates waterways and aquifers, poor waste
management, contaminated land, deforestation and
sporadic urbanization. Ecologically it is poor. As the
European and world's experience shows, many of
the nowadays healthy river waterfronts, were
polluted in the past, so the chances for reversing the
natural state are high.
“The peculiarity of Tirana stands in the fact that
post-socialist socio-spatial transformations are
better defined by Balkanization (implying
individuality and hostility) rather than segregation
(which implies clustering)” (Nase, Ocakçi. 2010).
The public space is missing, as it is made property
of the individuals which are settled in the area,
property of each one alone, not along with the
others. These individuals are interested in what
evolves inside the fence of their houses and feel like
lose character outside these borders. This kind of
mentality makes citizens of this area distinguish by
a special lifestyle, but not necessarily by good life
quality. The rejection of sharing space with others
leads to lack of social life, parks, recreational areas
etc.. Currently, users of the Paskuqan Park (what is
left from the public space) are relatively passive.
Furthermore, squares and roads do not seem to
provoke social cohesion, because of their structure,
their main function of mobility and accessibility
between different parts, their narrow or missing
sidewalks, the unsafety they offer etc. The area
speaks of a bad management of wastes and
potentials (resources) too. For example; the natural
lake of Paskuqan or the river of Tirana suffers from
waste and lack of maintenance, although they have
the opportunity to be a clear and real public space.
Primary activities are missing, so the functions that
take place are residential and rarely commercial
''
*''Illustrations: maps; sketches; short descriptive analyses''
 
 
<gallery caption= "Illustrations" widths="300px" heights="200px" perrow="3">
 
Image:Geomorfology of the site.jpg|Biogeograpy of the site
Image:existing_map.jpg|Stellite Map
Image:Tirana's Natural Boundaries.jpg|Tirana's Natural Boundaries
Image:Tirana_2004-07-14_-_Paskuqani aerial.jpg|Paskuqani lake aerial
Image:Study case area.jpg|Study case area
Image:Tirana rivers and lakes.jpg|Main river and lakes of the city
Image:Visualization_of_the_streets_and_urban_patterns.jpg|Street snd urban sprawl patterns
Image:Informal dwellings on the riverside.jpg|Informal dwellings on the riverside
Image:Paskuqani's lake north Tiana.jpg|Paskuqani's lake north Tiana
Image:Paskuqani's lake surroundings.jpg|Paskuqani's lake surroundings
Image:River of Tirana, bridge view 2.jpg|River of Tirana, bridge view 2
Image:River of Tirana, central bridge view 3.jpg|River of Tirana, central bridge view 3
Image:Strom-water inefficence.jpg|Strom-water inefficence
Image:Not functional grasslands near the river.jpg|Not functional grasslands near the river
 
</gallery>


== Analytical drawings ==
== Analytical drawings ==
''Please add four analytical sketches/drawings (or montages/schemes) of your case. Every group member needs to contribute at least one drawing.''
*''Please use analytical drawing for visualising the conflicts/potentials of your site''
 
<gallery caption="Analytical Drawings" widths="300px" heights="180px" perrow="4">
 
Image:Tirana landuse and informal settlements.jpg|Tirana landuse and informal settlements
Image:SWOT STRENGTHS.jpg|SWOT analysis Strengths
Image:SWOT_weaknesses.jpg|SWOT weaknesses
Image:SWOT opportunities.jpg|SWOT opportunities
Image:SWOT threats.jpg|SWOT threats
Image:Potential parks of Tirana.jpg|Potential parks of Tirana
 


<gallery caption="Analytical Drawings " widths="150px" heights="150px" perrow="4">
Image:yourfilename1.jpg|analytical drawing 1
Image:yourfilename2.jpg|analytical drawing 2
Image:yourfilename3.jpg|analytical drawing 3
Image:yourfilename4.jpg|analytical drawing 4
</gallery>
</gallery>
== Green Infrastructure benefits for this site ==
''Look again at the multiple benefits of green infrastructure - what could be achieved in your site and which are most relevant
The green infrastructure of this site aims to “restore” the river to its
condition of natural value and texture. This action can be accomplished by removing
rubbish and improve waste management.
The result will be the encouragement of
-social interaction, constitution of opportunities, tourist‟s
attraction, introduction of activities and interventions
platforms along the riverside area.
''
== Potential for multifunctionality ==
The result will come with:
'''Connectivity benefits:'''
1. Connection of people with the river /pedestrian paths
2. Connetion of the two sides of the rivers
3. With the future boulevard extension the north part of Tirana will become even more  close to the centre and will connect it with the north park of
4. Good possibility for developing alternative transport system like tram and bicycle.
'''
Social benefits:'''
1. Multi-functional public facilites
2. Improved air quality and life quality
3. Increased recreational spaces
4. Public education
5. Community cohesion
''''''
Environmental benefits:''''''
1. Increased biodiversity
2. Habitat improvement
3. Green technologies in the water management
'''
'''
Economic benefits:''''''
1. Increased property value
2. More job opportunities in planning and executing the project
3. Reduced grey infrastructure cost ( almost 50 %)
4. Solar energy development because of sunny weather
5. Making agriculture fields a means of economic benefit
''


== Projective drawings ==
== Projective drawings ==
''Please add four projective sketches/drawings (or montages/schemes), of course with an emphasis on green infrastructure aspects. Every group member needs to contribute at least one drawing representing his/her individual ideas.''
* ''How would you like this case to change in the near future? (in 1-2 years)''
** ''you may add a short explanation here''
 
* ''And how could it look like in 10-15 years?''
** ''you may add a short explanation here''


<gallery caption="Projective Drawings " widths="150px" heights="150px" perrow="4">
<gallery caption="Projective Drawings" widths="300px" heights="200px" perrow="4">
Image:yourfilename1.jpg|projective drawing 1
Image:Spatial concept.jpg|Spatial concept in 10-15 years
Image:yourfilename2.jpg|projective drawing 2
Image:River' parks proposals.jpg|River's parks proposal in 10-15 years
Image:yourfilename3.jpg|projective drawing 3
Image:Multifunctionality proposal.jpg|Multifunctionality proposal
Image:yourfilename4.jpg|projective drawing 4
Image:Restoration of the river.jpg|Restoration of the river
Image:Connectivity sections.jpg|Connectivity sections
</gallery>
</gallery>
== Design Synthesis ==
== Design Synthesis ==
''Please analyse the individual approaches presented so far and evaluate their strengths and weaknesses (you may use the [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SWOT_analysis SWOT]analysis model). Try to create a synthesis and represent it with a plan and some sketches. You can still use drawings/sketches.''
''Please analyse the individual approaches presented so far and evaluate their strengths and weaknesses (you may use the [http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/SWOT_analysis SWOT]analysis model). Try to create a synthesis and represent it with a plan and some sketches. You can still use drawings/sketches.''

Revision as of 23:24, 17 January 2015

---> back to group page working group C


Green/Blue Infrastructure of the urban area of the river of Tirana, ALBANIA


Name Green/blue infrastructure in north of Tirana
Country Albania
City Tirana
Authors Mirsa Gishti
River of Tirana.jpg

Rationale: Blue/green infrstructure-connecting the historic centre with the national park

The river of Tirana is located between the historic centre and the National Park of the Paskuqani in northern part of the city. It is one of the 5 developing poles of the multicentric masterplan of the city approved in 2012. The population is expeted to increase during the next years, according to the demographic data and this fact makes the river`s zone a potential area of high density and multifunctionality in the future. The landscape is shaped mostly by natural and seminatural features like hills, the river and the park. Currently informal buildings, waste pollution and low mantainance of ecologic environment has become a very big problem to solve. It is an emergency to approach the future development of the area based on a well integrated green/blue infrastructure project since nothing has been done in this aspect and planning is always a better choice than improving when is too late.

Author's perspective

I have a master degree in urban planning and a background in architecture. The area of the study case is located in the city where I have spent 12 years living. Beside that, my master thesis project was near the river of Tirana´s zone but my approach was focused on the southern part of it and on the new residential buildings proposal.

Landscape and/or urban context of your case

  • Biogeography, cultural features, overall character, history and dynamics


Overview of the city

Tirana, the capital of Albania, is situated 40 kilometers from Durres, the largest port in the country and 26 km from Mother Theresa International Airport. It is the largest city, with an increasing population, with an average annual growth rate of 3.77% from 2001–2009 (INSTAT, 2009). The faster urbanization influences the city's development, the living environment and the socioeconomic situation.Tirana has the opportunity to be regenerated itself after a long term of isolation. Exists a lot of informality in the northpart of the city, but this informality is supposed to be the shelter for those persons who live there.


Historical evolution.jpg


Biogeography of the area

Tirana‟s contact with water is concretized in two lakes (one in north and the other in south) and two rivers (Tirana River and Lana River) that run parallel to each other, between the two lakes. The actual condition of the Tirana River waterfront is weak and the regeneration of it is an important issue for the development of the city.


Its north-south axis, which eventually corresponds to the main boulevard of the city, serves as a connector between the lakes and the rivers. Existing general land use of the area under study and identification of the water surfaces of Tirana city. (Source: GrimShaw analysis and Dar analysis for Tirana Masterplan 2012) “Tirana in the XVI century was defined by a building mosque, a hammam and a bakery,” (Aliaj, Myftiu & Lulo, 2003). So, water was not the most important factor in the foundation of the city, but it was one of the natural resources affecting the growth of its early settlements and melding its future. In the actual situation, there do exist a close relationship between the water and the city. Like other natural elements (Dajti Mountain, hills, agriculture etc.) water influences the urban development and the stratum of the urban fabric.

The urbanization process happens on both sides of the Lana and Tirana River, around lakes. Tirana‟s green regions are strengthened by the topography besieging the urban superficies, the streets, the habitation areas etc. The source of Tirana River is in the mountains to the east. It flows to west through the northern area of the city. In the mountains, it flows through the protected area of Dajti Mountain, providing an ecological corridor, through which wildlife can extend and survive. Its estuary is 30-40 km to the north-west at Rodon Bay, on the Adriatic coast. The topography of Tirana from east to west is nearly 1% slope. The existing natural movement results fast during periods of rainfall, which combined with coarse sand and cobbles by the mountains located close, becomes a destructive force.



After the centralized society dropped to the market economy in the ‟90s, Tirana, as many other postsocialist cities of Europe, experienced an extensive growth by the congestion of the new population that settled in the periphery of it, which was not well incorporated into the urban life of the city. This decentralized action induced spontaneous settlement by the citizens, with their own resources, the same as it did in different places of the world, including Bogota, Bombay, Caracas etc., which suffer from a high percentage of informality. In Tirana, the social and spatial pattern viewpoint of the phenomena is little investigated.



The informal settlements (Kamza, Bathore and Paskuqan, the three major informal housing settlements around Tirana, with over 90% of the dwellings constructed illegally), grew mainly in the early 2000, in suspicious and poor conditions. This gave birth to an “informal city”, which was not acknowledged by the authorities, a self-made structure by rural immigrants which saw Tirana as a better opportunity for their familiar and future life. This city grew without planning control, creating a spatial and cultural disconnection with the existing urban situation. The consolidation of the “selfadding- process” raises the problems of social injury which needs to be resolved. The sustainable development of these areas, the integration and consolidation need a better understanding of these problems, to go to the final solutions. “The segregation involves spatial separation of population groups and spatial separation reduces interaction among groups over space” (Newby, 1982).


The existing condition of the Tirana river waterfront One of these informal areas is that of the North Tirana (Tirana River area near Paskuqan). The current ecological situation of the urban Tirana River demonstrates waterways and aquifers, poor waste management, contaminated land, deforestation and sporadic urbanization. Ecologically it is poor. As the European and world's experience shows, many of the nowadays healthy river waterfronts, were polluted in the past, so the chances for reversing the natural state are high. “The peculiarity of Tirana stands in the fact that post-socialist socio-spatial transformations are better defined by Balkanization (implying individuality and hostility) rather than segregation (which implies clustering)” (Nase, Ocakçi. 2010). The public space is missing, as it is made property of the individuals which are settled in the area, property of each one alone, not along with the others. These individuals are interested in what evolves inside the fence of their houses and feel like lose character outside these borders. This kind of mentality makes citizens of this area distinguish by a special lifestyle, but not necessarily by good life quality. The rejection of sharing space with others leads to lack of social life, parks, recreational areas etc.. Currently, users of the Paskuqan Park (what is left from the public space) are relatively passive. Furthermore, squares and roads do not seem to provoke social cohesion, because of their structure, their main function of mobility and accessibility between different parts, their narrow or missing sidewalks, the unsafety they offer etc. The area speaks of a bad management of wastes and potentials (resources) too. For example; the natural lake of Paskuqan or the river of Tirana suffers from waste and lack of maintenance, although they have the opportunity to be a clear and real public space. Primary activities are missing, so the functions that take place are residential and rarely commercial

  • Illustrations: maps; sketches; short descriptive analyses


Analytical drawings

  • Please use analytical drawing for visualising the conflicts/potentials of your site

Green Infrastructure benefits for this site

Look again at the multiple benefits of green infrastructure - what could be achieved in your site and which are most relevant

The green infrastructure of this site aims to “restore” the river to its condition of natural value and texture. This action can be accomplished by removing rubbish and improve waste management. The result will be the encouragement of -social interaction, constitution of opportunities, tourist‟s attraction, introduction of activities and interventions platforms along the riverside area.

Potential for multifunctionality

The result will come with:


Connectivity benefits:


1. Connection of people with the river /pedestrian paths

2. Connetion of the two sides of the rivers

3. With the future boulevard extension the north part of Tirana will become even more close to the centre and will connect it with the north park of

4. Good possibility for developing alternative transport system like tram and bicycle.


Social benefits:


1. Multi-functional public facilites

2. Improved air quality and life quality

3. Increased recreational spaces

4. Public education

5. Community cohesion


' Environmental benefits:'

1. Increased biodiversity

2. Habitat improvement

3. Green technologies in the water management


Economic benefits:'

1. Increased property value

2. More job opportunities in planning and executing the project

3. Reduced grey infrastructure cost ( almost 50 %)

4. Solar energy development because of sunny weather

5. Making agriculture fields a means of economic benefit


Projective drawings

  • How would you like this case to change in the near future? (in 1-2 years)
    • you may add a short explanation here
  • And how could it look like in 10-15 years?
    • you may add a short explanation here

Design Synthesis

Please analyse the individual approaches presented so far and evaluate their strengths and weaknesses (you may use the SWOTanalysis model). Try to create a synthesis and represent it with a plan and some sketches. You can still use drawings/sketches.

Summary of the collaborative process

Please reflect on your collaborative design process. Which potentials have you encountered? What was most difficult? What does collaborative design mean for you? (approx 150 words).

Image Gallery

You may add a series of images/photos in addition to the sketches/drawings


References

* Please make sure that you give proper references of all external resources used.

* Do not use images of which you do not hold the copyright.

* Please add internet links to other resources if necessary.



About categories: You can add more categories with this tag: "", add your categories