Rebuilding a Sustainable Image in a Cultural Landscape, Iran
Name | add the project name | |
Place | add the city name | |
Country | Iran | |
Author(s) | Roya Sabri | |
Project start | enter the date of the project start | |
Completion | enter the date of completion | |
World Heritage | enter the year of listing | |
Client | enter the client | |
Project costs | enter the costs (if known) | |
<googlemap version="0.9" lat="41.035859" lon="29.00116" zoom="9" width="400" height="300" controls="small"> </googlemap> | ||
Rationale: Why is the case study interesting?
- Please summarise:- e.g. Design Innovation? Planning Exemplar? Theoretical Insights? Lessons from its failure?
On December 26, 2003, an earthquake struck the city of Bam in Iran. While there have been numerous quakes in Iran (caused by the unique geology of the country) with a plethora of casualties, none have ever been as devastating as the damage caused by that earthquake in Bam. There are major lessons that can be learned from the Bam experience that can be applied to other similar situations. The relationship between nature and culture adds a significant insight into the complex situation where reconstruction extends beyond bricks and mortar to the reconstruction of lives and the continuation of nature. The participation of the local people is of vital importance. In Bam, a unique approach was used to recover cultural values and reach out to a segment of population that is vital to Bam's future, its children. The procedure for reconstruction involved Bam's children in a UNICEF workshop and provided a way to involve them in the design of parts of the environment through their own eyes. The workshops not only provided insight for a better reconstruction of the city, but also hope in the midst of a disaster.
Author's perspective
- What theoretical or professional perspective do you bring to the case study? Please make a short note on your personal background
Cultural landscape context
- Biogeography, cultural features, overall landscape character, history and dynamics
Illustration: Map; sketches; short descriptive analyses
Built upon historic cultural traditions, the culture of
Bam is further tempered by the extremes of the desert
environment, extremes that demand both patience and
respect. From an historic standpoint Bam, is a symbol
of man’s ability to survive in a hostile environment,
but more importantly Bam represents man’s ability to
live in harmony with a very fragile and constraining
environment. Bam is very unique in this sense. The
diverse, tangible and intangible heritage of Bam also
reflects values associated with the long and complex
history of the city. Bam and its surroundings are a
cultural landscape composed of the desert
environment; an ingenious water use, management and
distribution system; agricultural land use; gardens and
built environment. It has not only a complex,
underground irrigation system leading to an
agricultural land use network that is in harmony with
its built area, but also it is a network of gardens mixed
into the urban fabric which extend to the outskirts of
the town.The hostile environment and the enclosures
protecting the city are a common feature that connects
the Persian city of Bam with all medieval cities in the
world. In all cases massive walls are erected to defend
the city from threatening circumstances. Of course
similarity of form does not always result from
sameness of causes, so the "internality" of Bam, as
opposed to the other medieval cities, is not a mere
defense against military attacks. It depicts a similarity
of process in fending off an unfriendly and harsh
environment. However, in the case of Bam, a city
surrounded by hot climatic conditions and sand
storms, the enclosing fortress and walls create a city of
hospitable, simple and beautiful, internal spaces.
Socio-political context
- Brief explanation of political economy, legal framework
Illustration: Bullet points, image, background notes
The existence of Bam and its gardens are dependent on the presence and ability to distribute water. The Persian Gardens of Bam are an example of a live micro ecosystem that has evolved from within. The gardens owe their liveliness to the internal forces of water coming from the ancient subterranean canals or qanats6 which make the vast palm groves flourish. This age-old technology was believed to have been devised 2,500 years ago at the time of the founder of the Persian Empire, Cyrus the Great. The route of these underground canals determines the capacity and direction of the growth of the city. The routes can be traced by the pot holes (Figure 4) left from the initial excavations and the subsequent repairs, as well as, the linear grove of willow trees that direct the eye toward the main form of the settlement. The complex irrigation system is a testimony to an extraordinary level of an advanced culture that existed in ancient Persia. The failure or lack of attention to the qanats could have lead to the death of the city of Bam at any time during the past 2500 years. Yet, the city of Bam currently has about 370 active qanats. The system has survived the earthquake and is producing water today. Persian culture is intertwined with the implications and meanings of the Persian Garden. A concept of internal and external worlds, which in the words of Arthur Upham Pope, is mesmerizing: “Within all is calm. The garden becomes the still point in a turning world, a field of constant and subtle change held in delicate balance by manmade design.” The garden, as an artifact created by inhabitants inside the urban fabric, establishes a relationship between the cultural worlds of its creators and the natural environment of its context. Understanding this concept of the garden in Bam is crucial in regenerating the devastated city (Figure 5). In this regard, the palm in the local culture is not a mere tree, but also a member of the family and the sign of life. Measuring units in Farsi are different for a person as compared to a thing, and as for the palm tree, it is counted as a person. According to folk tales palms are such sensitive plants that their annual products depend on the constant attention of the gardener. There are ceremonies in which the gardener pretends to cut the tree because it has been unproductive and the neighbors try tomediate between them; surprisingly the tree will reproduce in the proceeding year. In this sense man and cultivation fit into nature in a dialogue between elements and their surroundings. Gardens in Bam are also a source of relationship with the outside world. As a leading world producer of dates and their by products resulting in a viable economy, Bam has had a transactional system between inside and outside worlds that has been always dependent on the gardens. The process of making date by products, such as cookies, is depicted in a mural on the walls near the Citadel (Figure 6). From the ancient times Bam has possessed a commercial identity, since it was situated along the ancient Silk Road. Located at the centre of the known world, Bam served as the crossroads of the major trading routes, bringing the treasures of the Far East to Persia and Europe and of course the caravans did not leave the gardens of Bam empty handed. Thus, the symbolism, vivid memories and mental images of the inhabitants can best be retrieved through the restoration of the gardens as living places. As is the case with Tabas7, another Persian city in the desert devastated by an earthquake about 25 years earlier, Bam continues to exist as long as the gardens survive (Figure 7). The gardens and the irrigation system, as natural artifacts, in harmony with economy and technology, as the virtual network of relations, create a framework in which hidden patterns come to life. Accordingly, the attained patterns have led to a comprehensive plan for the city in which the physical structures are formed from the natural elements intertwined with the cultural expressions. The inhabitants have vanished in vast areas of the city, but finite patterns of interactions, techniques, customs and beliefs are laid out and ready to be reborn in an eminent culture. The green patches of palm trees all over the city are more discernible since the urban fabric is in ruins. About 80% of the buildings were leveled by the earthquake8.
Spatial analysis of area/project
- What are the main structural features?
- How has it been shaped? Were there any critical decisions?
Illustration: Map/diagram/sketches photos and background notes
Traveling to Bam, a historic oasis city was once one of the most desirable destinations for a tourist in Iran. This trip was never complete without a visit to its prominent landmark, Arg-e-Bam or the Citadel. The significance of the Citadel is not only related to its unique architectural features, which have placed it on the World Heritage List2, but also the cultural traditions and memories of the place. For instance some local residents, bound to ancient Iranian traditions, used the height of the upper fort to salute the arrival of spring on the occasion of the Iranian New Year. The Citadel, a giant adobe structure, is located on a steep rock surrounded by desert as far as eyes can see. Until recent times, residents inhabited the Citadel and tended to their gardens outside the Citadel on the plain below. The plan of the Citadel reveals its efficiency and self-sufficiency with an array of public spaces, such as: the Bazaar, a small mosque, a theological school, a caravanserai, a water reservoir, the square, a bathhouse, a gymnasium and some older and more elaborate houses of the aristocrats. The Citadel of Bam (Arg-e Bam) is considered “the largest extant mud brick complex of its type in the world which has kept its traditional architecture and town planning undisturbed by alien elements until now.”3 The devastating earthquake, measuring 6.8 on the Richter scale by some estimates, has destroyed up to 60% of the compound4 (Figure 1). Today after many months the experts at the Iran Cultural Heritage Organization are still painstakingly sifting through the rubble to put pieces of tile and brick back together (Figure 2)5 . The Citadel is the place where the entire city comes into the view. The greenest fields amid the sandy desert are some of the most enduring images in the Persian landscape ( Mohajeri Baradaran, 2005). And here, on top of the hill, where the ruler used to live, one should not miss the panoramic views over the endless desert to the north, the oasis town of Bam to the east and an impenetrable mountain range to the south. The internal experience of the site is joined with external qualities of the context, establishing a relationship between the Citadel, the gardens and the entire city. In restoring this valuable landmark it is fitting to use the original techniques and methods from the vernacular lessons of the past. The use of mud or adobe brick making is a case in point (Figure 3).
Analysis of idea/program/function ("Planning Objective")
- What are the main functional characteristics?
- How have they been expressed or incorporated?
Illustration: Map/diagram/sketches photos and background notes
Analysis of design/planning process ("Process Biography")
- How was the area/project formulated and implemented?
- Who initiated the project and why?
- Which stakeholders have been involved?
- Who made the major decisions and when?
- Were there any important consultations/collaborations?
Illustration: Map/diagram/sketches photos and background notes
Analysis of use/users
- How is the area/project used and by whom?
- Is the use changing? Are there any issues?
Illustration: Map/diagram/sketches photos and background notes
Future development directions
- How is the area/project evolving?
- Are there any future goals?
Illustration: Map/diagram/sketches photos and background notes
Peer reviews or critique
- Has the area/project been reviewed by academic or professional reviewers?
- What were their main evaluations?
Please add references, quotes...
Successes and limitations
- What do you see as the main successes and limitations of the area/project?
Illustration: Summary table
What can be generalized from this case study?
- Are there any important theoretical insights?
Short statement plus background notes
What research questions does it generate?
Short statement plus background notes
Image Gallery
DSC00797.jpg
- Yourimage.jpg
your image text and source
- Yourimage.jpg
your image text and source
- Yourimage.jpg
your image text and source
- Yourimage.jpg
your image text and source
- Yourimage.jpg
your image text and source
- Yourimage.jpg
your image text and source
- Yourimage.jpg
your image text and source
- Yourimage.jpg
your image text and source
References
Botkin, D. and K. Edward (1998). Environmental Science: Earth as a Living Planet. London: John Wiley and Sons Inc.
De luce, J., B. Dewight and C. Pletsch (1993). Beyond Preservation. Minnesota: University of Press.
Gibson, J. J. (1979). The Ecological Approach to Visual Perception. Boston: Houghton Mifflin.
Gussow, A. (1979). A Sense of Place: The Artists and the American Land, A Continuum Book, NY.
Houghton, M., and G. A. Boston (1979). A Sense of Place: The Artists and the American Land. NY: A Continuum Book.
Kaplan, S.(1979). Perception and Landscape: Conceptions and Misconceptions.
Malloy, J. (2003). Woman, Art, and Technology. Mass: MIT Press, Cambridge.
Meyer, S. M. (2004). End of the Wild. The Boston Review, April-May.
Mitchell, W. J. (1972). Environmental Design Research and Practice, Proceedings of the EDRA Conference. LA: University of California Los Angeles Publication.
Norman, D. A. (1990). The Design of Everyday Things, NY: Doubleday.
Pierssene. A. (1999). Explaining Our World: an Approach to the Art of Environmental Interpretation. London: E&FN Spon.
Rice-Oxley, M. (2004). Walkers Face off in Tragicomic Struggle. The Christian Science Monitory, May 18.
Sabri, C. R. (2006). The Role of Nature on Design. An Academic Research for Shahid Beheshti University.
Sonfist, A. (1983). Art in the Land: A Critical Anthology of Environmental Art. NY: Dutton Publication.
Susanka, S. (2004). The Not so Big House. Taunton Press.
Weintraub. L. (1984). Land Marks. NY: Bard College Center.