Working Group Public Space and Civic Identity - Revision history

WikiSysop: /* Answers of the Case Studies */

2013-08-03T14:43:48Z

Answers of the Case Studies

← Older revision		Revision as of 14:43, 3 August 2013
Line 32:		Line 32:
	Agnieska , Harun		Agnieska , Harun
	==== Answers of the Case Studies ====		==== Answers of the Case Studies ====
	<~~DPL~~>		<DynamicPageList>
	category=Working Group Public Space and Civic Identity		category=Working Group Public Space and Civic Identity
	mode=ordered		mode=ordered
	include = #Who was involved in the participation process?		include = #Who was involved in the participation process?
	</~~DPL~~>		</DynamicPageList>

	==== Synthesis ====		==== Synthesis ====

WikiSysop: /* Case Studies of this working group */

2013-08-03T14:43:31Z

Case Studies of this working group

← Older revision		Revision as of 14:43, 3 August 2013
Line 5:		Line 5:
	[[Category:Working Group Public Space and Civic Identity]]		[[Category:Working Group Public Space and Civic Identity]]

	<~~DPL~~>		<DynamicPageList>
	category=Working Group Public Space and Civic Identity		category=Working Group Public Space and Civic Identity
	mode=ordered		mode=ordered
	include = #Rationale: Why is this case study interesting?		include = #Rationale: Why is this case study interesting?
	</~~DPL~~>		</DynamicPageList>
	[[#toc\|'''Back to top''']]		[[#toc\|'''Back to top''']]

	== Core Questions of this Working Group ==		== Core Questions of this Working Group ==

Agnieszka Gorniak: /* Synthesis */

2009-02-22T12:07:53Z

Synthesis

← Older revision		Revision as of 12:07, 22 February 2009
Line 37:		Line 37:
	</DPL>		</DPL>
	==== Synthesis ====		==== Synthesis ====

			The core question have been summarized by Agnieszka Górniak and Harun Ekinoglu based on information provided by Public Space and Civic Identity working group.
			The particular information have been synthesized in form of table by Harun. The identification of the participants and clustering have been prepared as diagram and summarized by Agnieszka.


	[[Image:Aga2.jpg]]		[[Image:Aga2.jpg]]
Line 42:		Line 46:
	[[Image:summary1.jpg]]		[[Image:summary1.jpg]]

	~~[[#toc\|'''Back to top''']]~~

	Short Summary:		Short Summary:

	Based on information above the participants in the process of creation of public spaces have been indentified and clustered ~~here~~ in four groups according to the specific phases of realization of the projects:		Based on information above the participants in the process of creation of public spaces have been indentified and clustered in four groups according to the specific phases of realization of the projects:
	- the initiators that indicated the ideas and kicked-off the ~~project~~		- the initiators that indicated the ideas and kicked-off the projects
	- the ~~analyst~~ and designers that ~~create~~ the physical structure of the area according to spatial conditions and identified needs of users		- the analysts and designers that createed the physical structure of the area according to spatial conditions and identified needs of users
	- the constructors that ~~implement~~ the ~~project~~		- the constructors that implemented the projects
	- the attendants that cultivate and develop the area		- the attendants that cultivate and develop the area
	The public spaces should serve the public, so they have to respond to the needs of their users. The adequate identification of the final beneficiaries (users) of the public space and invitation them to participate in all the process of realization are a key to the success. The more diversified participants the completer list users’ expectation and needs. The participation of final users in realization of public spaces may also help to integrate the local community and build the commitments between society and place.		The public spaces should serve the public, so they have to respond to the needs of their users. The adequate identification of the final beneficiaries (users) of the public space and invitation them to participate in all the process of realization are a key to the success. The more diversified participants the completer list users’ expectation and needs. The participation of final users in realization of public spaces may also help to integrate the local community and build the commitments between society and place.


			[[#toc\|'''Back to top''']]

	=== How was the participation process implemented (methods applied)? ===		=== How was the participation process implemented (methods applied)? ===

Agnieszka Gorniak: /* Synthesis */

2009-02-22T11:26:27Z

Synthesis

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:26, 22 February 2009
Line 43:		Line 43:

	[[#toc\|'''Back to top''']]		[[#toc\|'''Back to top''']]

			Short Summary:

			Based on information above the participants in the process of creation of public spaces have been indentified and clustered here in four groups according to the specific phases of realization of the projects:
			- the initiators that indicated the ideas and kicked-off the project
			- the analyst and designers that create the physical structure of the area according to spatial conditions and identified needs of users
			- the constructors that implement the project
			- the attendants that cultivate and develop the area
			The public spaces should serve the public, so they have to respond to the needs of their users. The adequate identification of the final beneficiaries (users) of the public space and invitation them to participate in all the process of realization are a key to the success. The more diversified participants the completer list users’ expectation and needs. The participation of final users in realization of public spaces may also help to integrate the local community and build the commitments between society and place.

	=== How was the participation process implemented (methods applied)? ===		=== How was the participation process implemented (methods applied)? ===

Agnieszka Gorniak: /* Synthesis */

2009-02-22T11:01:23Z

Synthesis

← Older revision		Revision as of 11:01, 22 February 2009
Line 40:		Line 40:
	[[Image:Aga2.jpg]]		[[Image:Aga2.jpg]]

	[[Image:~~Prezentacja_IMLA1~~.jpg]]		[[Image:summary1.jpg]]

	[[#toc\|'''Back to top''']]		[[#toc\|'''Back to top''']]

Agnieszka Gorniak: /* Synthesis */

2009-02-22T10:45:52Z

Synthesis

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:45, 22 February 2009
Line 40:		Line 40:
	[[Image:Aga2.jpg]]		[[Image:Aga2.jpg]]

	[[Image:~~Prezentacja_IMLA~~.jpg]]		[[Image:Prezentacja_IMLA1.jpg]]

	[[#toc\|'''Back to top''']]		[[#toc\|'''Back to top''']]

La2994: /* Analysis */

2009-01-31T10:57:52Z

Analysis

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:57, 31 January 2009
Line 232:		Line 232:


	Thematic clusters:		Thematic clusters (see also analytical drawing below):

	Cluster 1: Amelioration of physical, social, economical and legal conditions		Cluster 1: Amelioration of physical, social, economical and legal conditions

La2994: /* Analysis */

2009-01-31T10:56:10Z

Analysis

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:56, 31 January 2009
Line 235:		Line 235:

	Cluster 1: Amelioration of physical, social, economical and legal conditions		Cluster 1: Amelioration of physical, social, economical and legal conditions

	Cluster 2: Creation of free space, recreation, regeneration		Cluster 2: Creation of free space, recreation, regeneration

	Cluster 3: Preserving identity and evocation of personal relations to the site		Cluster 3: Preserving identity and evocation of personal relations to the site

La2994: /* Analysis */

2009-01-31T10:54:57Z

Analysis

La2994: /* Summary */

2009-01-31T10:54:13Z

Summary

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:54, 31 January 2009
Line 188:		Line 188:
	The improvement of physical conditions in the slum bore some significant outcomes, for example high quality public spaces. But it should be more efforts in order to guarantee the livelihoods beyond the traditional approach such as housing and infrastructure. Furthermore it's important to improve the integration and the amount of comprehensiveness.		The improvement of physical conditions in the slum bore some significant outcomes, for example high quality public spaces. But it should be more efforts in order to guarantee the livelihoods beyond the traditional approach such as housing and infrastructure. Furthermore it's important to improve the integration and the amount of comprehensiveness.

	Parks in Neu Oerlikon:		- Parks in Neu Oerlikon:
	The four parks have a high artistic quality and were made for creating free space. The Wahlen Park is also used as a school meadow and is accepted well. The MFO Park reminds of the original buildings, is designed in different levels and some attractions are temporary or long-term existing. The Oerliker Park is seen as worse integrated and the idea, that users affect a new appearance of the park, doesn’t work yet. The lower utilization leads back to the very far construction of the new quarter Oerlikon within 5 years. As a result there is a lack of development, less own character and clinical, empty feeling.		The four parks have a high artistic quality and were made for creating free space. The Wahlen Park is also used as a school meadow and is accepted well. The MFO Park reminds of the original buildings, is designed in different levels and some attractions are temporary or long-term existing. The Oerliker Park is seen as worse integrated and the idea, that users affect a new appearance of the park, doesn’t work yet. The lower utilization leads back to the very far construction of the new quarter Oerlikon within 5 years. As a result there is a lack of development, less own character and clinical, empty feeling.

	Paseo del Buen Pastor:		- Paseo del Buen Pastor:
	It fulfills the need of a new open place, of having alternatives for activities as well as the possibility for interactions with the society through art, culture and history in order to reinforce the identity.		It fulfills the need of a new open place, of having alternatives for activities as well as the possibility for interactions with the society through art, culture and history in order to reinforce the identity.

	Petuelpark:		- Petuelpark:
	It responds to the need of having a green space for recreation. There are many different elements and possibilities for individual leisure activities, but it's a decrease while wintertime. Works of art, individual designed places and furniture and the typical style of the park, fulfills the requirement of having a unique place with own character.		It responds to the need of having a green space for recreation. There are many different elements and possibilities for individual leisure activities, but it's a decrease while wintertime. Works of art, individual designed places and furniture and the typical style of the park, fulfills the requirement of having a unique place with own character.

	Suleymaniye Regeneration Area:		- Suleymaniye Regeneration Area:
	The ambition is to reach social and economical integration joint together to physical interventions.		The ambition is to reach social and economical integration joint together to physical interventions.

	Sulzer Factory Area:		- Sulzer Factory Area:
	This area is marked by its need for adaptability. Nowadays, the human were brought into focus and the space is used as place of congregation.		This area is marked by its need for adaptability. Nowadays, the human were brought into focus and the space is used as place of congregation.

	Uggledal:		- Uggledal:
	It was a wish of the planner to preserve the specialties and characteristics of this area. So the local inhabitants who had ecological ambitions participate while the planning process. But the new inhabitant had aesthetic preferences.		It was a wish of the planner to preserve the specialties and characteristics of this area. So the local inhabitants who had ecological ambitions participate while the planning process. But the new inhabitant had aesthetic preferences.

← Older revision		Revision as of 10:54, 31 January 2009
Line 208:		Line 208:
	==== Analysis ====		==== Analysis ====
	Commonalities and important points:		Commonalities and important points:

	In all cases, they try to respond to people’s requirements and wishes, mostly by dint of public participation. As well, there is the aim to integrate people, whether trough the participatory process itself or through the level of acceptance and usage. Although the projects have/had different ways of integration, the goals to reach bear a resemblance to each other centered at the end outcomes.		In all cases, they try to respond to people’s requirements and wishes, mostly by dint of public participation. As well, there is the aim to integrate people, whether trough the participatory process itself or through the level of acceptance and usage. Although the projects have/had different ways of integration, the goals to reach bear a resemblance to each other centered at the end outcomes.
	Furthermore, every place and park was made in order to improve living conditions (in the majority of by creating regeneration and recreation areas) and to identify people with its surrounding society.		Furthermore, every place and park was made in order to improve living conditions (in the majority of by creating regeneration and recreation areas) and to identify people with its surrounding society.


	Gaps and discrepances:		Gaps and discrepances:

	In general, it’s not possible to fulfill all requirements, because one can’t cover the whole range of human needs. There will be always a lack of sufficiency.		In general, it’s not possible to fulfill all requirements, because one can’t cover the whole range of human needs. There will be always a lack of sufficiency.
	Besides, by planning for future users, you can only suppose what kind of persons will utilize it.		Besides, by planning for future users, you can only suppose what kind of persons will utilize it.


	Unusual approaches:		Unusual approaches:

	Case study Medellin: Upgrading social conditions by means of physical condition improvements.		Case study Medellin: Upgrading social conditions by means of physical condition improvements.
	Case study Suleymanlye Regeneration Area: The ambition is to reach social and economical integration joint together to physical interventions.		Case study Suleymanlye Regeneration Area: The ambition is to reach social and economical integration joint together to physical interventions.
	This unusual approach (for the western point of view) is caused by stronger physical, social and economical conditions, which are typical in some countries.		This unusual approach (for the western point of view) is caused by stronger physical, social and economical conditions, which are typical in some countries.


	Main differences between the case studies:		Main differences between the case studies:

	Different amount of fulfillment: There is a range of total completion until no one.		Different amount of fulfillment: There is a range of total completion until no one.
	Different ways to fulfill people’s requirements: Participation, Improvement of physical, economical or legal conditions, creation of free space and recreation areas, conservation of identity, activation of interactions, ecological and environmental ambitions, art and history,		Different ways to fulfill people’s requirements: Participation, Improvement of physical, economical or legal conditions, creation of free space and recreation areas, conservation of identity, activation of interactions, ecological and environmental ambitions, art and history,


	Thematic clusters:		Thematic clusters:

	Cluster 1: Amelioration of physical, social, economical and legal conditions		Cluster 1: Amelioration of physical, social, economical and legal conditions
	Cluster 2: Creation of free space, recreation, regeneration		Cluster 2: Creation of free space, recreation, regeneration