Case Study Tartu 3 - Revision history

WikiSysop at 17:03, 7 December 2010

2010-12-07T17:03:31Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 17:03, 7 December 2010
Line 22:		Line 22:
	\| \|\|style="background:Lavender"\|		\| \|\|style="background:Lavender"\|
	\|-		\|-
	\| colspan="3" align="center" style="background:silver"\| <googlemap version="0.9" lat="~~-23~~.~~581609~~" lon="~~-46~~.~~590271" type="satellite~~" zoom="9" width="300" height="~~250~~">		\| colspan="3" align="center" style="background:silver"\| <googlemap version="0.9" lat="59.43434" lon="24.745846" zoom="13" width="300" height="300">
	</googlemap>		</googlemap>
	\|}		\|}

WeiWang: /* Core Question 2: What is the role of landscape architecture in this project? */

2010-11-24T21:18:27Z

Core Question 2: What is the role of landscape architecture in this project?

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:18, 24 November 2010
Line 90:		Line 90:

	Cities are where people live together, compared to the rural landscape and the function of the urban landscape is more comprehensive. Just Like the indenpent square, as it provides a positive space, there is no conflict between the function of commerial and the function of people's leisure and entertainment, but there is a good combination.I think this is characteristic of many European cities, as the same time it is just the advantages of City Square in European.		Cities are where people live together, compared to the rural landscape and the function of the urban landscape is more comprehensive. Just Like the indenpent square, as it provides a positive space, there is no conflict between the function of commerial and the function of people's leisure and entertainment, but there is a good combination.I think this is characteristic of many European cities, as the same time it is just the advantages of City Square in European.


			'''Comment to work of Tartu from Montevideo:'''

			Just in September 2010 a group of architects won the architectural competition for the redesign of our Independence Square in Montevideo. Citizens of Montevideo are now looking at the plans. And many people say: Who did ask us what we wanted?
			And we ask you, if the problems with the Statue of Liberty in the Square of Tallinn did not happen because people were not consulted before the redesign. Maybe the role of a landscape architect in such a project should consider the public consultation like in the Punta Yeguas Park.

	=== Image Gallery ===		=== Image Gallery ===

WeiWang: /* Core Question 1: In how far does this project reveal your concept of future landscapes? */

2010-11-24T21:15:59Z

Core Question 1: In how far does this project reveal your concept of future landscapes?

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:15, 24 November 2010
Line 32:		Line 32:

	In this case, we are more concerned with the square itself - which are relatively independent landscape form in shape and structure. For the Square, its own structure is relatively simple. However, such a single structure and spatial characteristics enable people to use it freedom and more selections, which also making the landscape into landscape with diversity.		In this case, we are more concerned with the square itself - which are relatively independent landscape form in shape and structure. For the Square, its own structure is relatively simple. However, such a single structure and spatial characteristics enable people to use it freedom and more selections, which also making the landscape into landscape with diversity.

			'''Comment to work of Tartu from Montevideo:'''

			The Independence Square in Tallinn is a typical example for an urban space with an important history and which needs to connect different parts of the city. As far as society needs a place which represents it, these squares will be part of our future landscape.

	=== Landscape and/or urban context===		=== Landscape and/or urban context===

Kunz: /* Core Question 1: In how far does this project reveal your concept of future landscapes? */

2010-11-23T08:45:31Z

Core Question 1: In how far does this project reveal your concept of future landscapes?

← Older revision		Revision as of 08:45, 23 November 2010
Line 28:		Line 28:
	=== <font color=darkblue size=4>Core Question 1:</font> In how far does this project reveal your concept of future landscapes? ===		=== <font color=darkblue size=4>Core Question 1:</font> In how far does this project reveal your concept of future landscapes? ===
	Life in the city is changing as well as the purpose of different landscapes in it. City squares are a nodal point where people do not walk only one way or another, they form their own routes – they have more opportunities, more freedom to do it. The squares are becoming more important for people to entertain themselves and get positive emotions. It does not mean that the squares lose their usage as markets or gathering places, but emphasis is slowly moving from one to another.		Life in the city is changing as well as the purpose of different landscapes in it. City squares are a nodal point where people do not walk only one way or another, they form their own routes – they have more opportunities, more freedom to do it. The squares are becoming more important for people to entertain themselves and get positive emotions. It does not mean that the squares lose their usage as markets or gathering places, but emphasis is slowly moving from one to another.

			'''Comments from kassel university:'''

			In this case, we are more concerned with the square itself - which are relatively independent landscape form in shape and structure. For the Square, its own structure is relatively simple. However, such a single structure and spatial characteristics enable people to use it freedom and more selections, which also making the landscape into landscape with diversity.

	=== Landscape and/or urban context===		=== Landscape and/or urban context===

Kunz: /* Core Question 2: What is the role of landscape architecture in this project? */

2010-11-23T08:44:46Z

Core Question 2: What is the role of landscape architecture in this project?

← Older revision		Revision as of 08:44, 23 November 2010
Line 79:		Line 79:


	Comments from kassel university:		'''Comments from kassel university:'''

	Cities are where people live together, compared to the rural landscape and the function of the urban landscape is more comprehensive. Just Like the indenpent square, as it provides a positive space, there is no conflict between the function of commerial and the function of people's leisure and entertainment, but there is a good combination.I think this is characteristic of many European cities, as the same time it is just the advantages of City Square in European.		Cities are where people live together, compared to the rural landscape and the function of the urban landscape is more comprehensive. Just Like the indenpent square, as it provides a positive space, there is no conflict between the function of commerial and the function of people's leisure and entertainment, but there is a good combination.I think this is characteristic of many European cities, as the same time it is just the advantages of City Square in European.

Kunz: /* Core Question 2: What is the role of landscape architecture in this project? */

2010-11-23T08:44:26Z

Core Question 2: What is the role of landscape architecture in this project?

← Older revision		Revision as of 08:44, 23 November 2010
Line 78:		Line 78:
	The role of landscape architecture in this project is the purpose of the square and the buildings around it – the square is presenting them (the square connects two very important churches in Estonia). It is possible to describe a square with the buildings that are surrounding it or different views that open to people when they are on it. When it comes to this particular square, Vabaduse väljak, you could say that it has no definite borders as it is situated in the middle of the city, but the architects have tried to give the borders by placing lamp posts to one side and a colorful wall to the other to make the space more obvious and bring it out a bit more. In addition, there are some constructions on the square that match the environment and typology and develop it.		The role of landscape architecture in this project is the purpose of the square and the buildings around it – the square is presenting them (the square connects two very important churches in Estonia). It is possible to describe a square with the buildings that are surrounding it or different views that open to people when they are on it. When it comes to this particular square, Vabaduse väljak, you could say that it has no definite borders as it is situated in the middle of the city, but the architects have tried to give the borders by placing lamp posts to one side and a colorful wall to the other to make the space more obvious and bring it out a bit more. In addition, there are some constructions on the square that match the environment and typology and develop it.


			Comments from kassel university:
			Cities are where people live together, compared to the rural landscape and the function of the urban landscape is more comprehensive. Just Like the indenpent square, as it provides a positive space, there is no conflict between the function of commerial and the function of people's leisure and entertainment, but there is a good combination.I think this is characteristic of many European cities, as the same time it is just the advantages of City Square in European.

	=== Image Gallery ===		=== Image Gallery ===

Erika at 21:30, 21 November 2010

2010-11-21T21:30:57Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:30, 21 November 2010
Line 89:		Line 89:
	Image:The statue of liberty.jpg\|The Statue of Liberty		Image:The statue of liberty.jpg\|The Statue of Liberty
	Image:At night.jpg\|The Statue of Liberty at night		Image:At night.jpg\|The Statue of Liberty at night
	Image:IMGP0417(2).JPG		Image:IMGP0417(2).JPG\| Player: She is a landscape architect who is studying in Tartu, but her family lives in Tallinn. Once a month, she goes home, and notes the changes in the city better than those who live there all the time.
			Image:IMGP0417.JPG\| Her day: She reads the news about what is happening in the city and decides to return home. She is going to look at the new architecture built. She arrives in town by train and walking through the old town. She goes through the Vabaduse Square in order to arrive at the bus stop. Tired of the long train journey, she eats a sandwich in Vabaduse Square. Sitting on the bench on Vabaduse Square, she admires skater skills.
	</gallery>		</gallery>

Erika at 21:06, 21 November 2010

2010-11-21T21:06:46Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 21:06, 21 November 2010
Line 89:		Line 89:
	Image:The statue of liberty.jpg\|The Statue of Liberty		Image:The statue of liberty.jpg\|The Statue of Liberty
	Image:At night.jpg\|The Statue of Liberty at night		Image:At night.jpg\|The Statue of Liberty at night
			Image:IMGP0417(2).JPG
	</gallery>		</gallery>

Triinorav at 20:58, 21 November 2010

2010-11-21T20:58:20Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:58, 21 November 2010
Line 1:		Line 1:
	---> back to overview of [[Future Landscapes Group 5]]		---> back to overview of [[Future Landscapes Group 5]]

	'''~~add your~~ case study ~~title~~''' by ''~~add authors~~''		'''The case study of Vabaduse Väljak (The Independence Square) in Tallinn''' by ''Anne Erik and Triin Orav''

Triinorav at 20:56, 21 November 2010

2010-11-21T20:56:33Z

← Older revision		Revision as of 20:56, 21 November 2010
Line 37:		Line 37:
	The architects have designed a square that considers the historical architectural heritage, typology of the ground and future perspectives. The most important reason for building the square is to continue the net of green and recreational areas that are situated in the old bastions of the city wall.		The architects have designed a square that considers the historical architectural heritage, typology of the ground and future perspectives. The most important reason for building the square is to continue the net of green and recreational areas that are situated in the old bastions of the city wall.


	~~Illustration:~~
	~~Map; sketches; short descriptive analyses~~

	=== Cultural/social/political context===		=== Cultural/social/political context===
Line 45:		Line 42:
	As a fortress surrounded by a wall Tallinn is a medieval legacy. Tallinn became an industrial city in Czarist Russia in the 20th century, and in 1920 the capital of the Republic of Estonia. The city started to develop behind the city walls and they were demolished. In 2006 when Tallinn could become the Cultural Capital of Europe the creation of a representative city square became more important.		As a fortress surrounded by a wall Tallinn is a medieval legacy. Tallinn became an industrial city in Czarist Russia in the 20th century, and in 1920 the capital of the Republic of Estonia. The city started to develop behind the city walls and they were demolished. In 2006 when Tallinn could become the Cultural Capital of Europe the creation of a representative city square became more important.

	~~Illustration:~~
	~~Bullet points, image, background notes~~

	=== Spatial analysis of area/project/plan===		=== Spatial analysis of area/project/plan===
Line 54:		Line 49:
	Plan provides estate connecting ranging between the Vabaduse square Kaarli avenue and bastion wall. An open city square and underground parking will be built on the estate. In addition to the parking below ground there will also be a large commercial area with pedestrian tunnel, which can be accessed from a spacious stairway constructed on Vabaduse square. With constructing the underground parking lot Vabaduse square becomes the State Office Square and the pedestrian area is suitable for the capital. New Square is deflected around the bastion and combines so far scattered urban space elements with cityscape as a whole. Vabaduse Square has no longer very clear boundaries, they are distributed.		Plan provides estate connecting ranging between the Vabaduse square Kaarli avenue and bastion wall. An open city square and underground parking will be built on the estate. In addition to the parking below ground there will also be a large commercial area with pedestrian tunnel, which can be accessed from a spacious stairway constructed on Vabaduse square. With constructing the underground parking lot Vabaduse square becomes the State Office Square and the pedestrian area is suitable for the capital. New Square is deflected around the bastion and combines so far scattered urban space elements with cityscape as a whole. Vabaduse Square has no longer very clear boundaries, they are distributed.

	~~Illustration: Map/diagram/sketches photos and background notes~~

	=== Analysis of program/function ===		=== Analysis of program/function ===
Line 62:		Line 56:
	So that the space would be perceived the edges are marked with the various architectural elements - high lamp posts, colored glass walls, massive guards ... but they are half-transparent, allowing the simultaneous presence of several different spaces.		So that the space would be perceived the edges are marked with the various architectural elements - high lamp posts, colored glass walls, massive guards ... but they are half-transparent, allowing the simultaneous presence of several different spaces.

	~~Illustration: Map/diagram/sketches photos and background notes~~

	=== Analysis of design/planning process ===		=== Analysis of design/planning process ===
Line 70:		Line 63:
	The architectural competition to the area has been held a few times before the project that was finally built was chosen. The last competition, that ended in 1998 had given a very good project, but as there was no political will, the project was never put into practice. In 2011 Tallinn is going to be the Cultural Capital of Europe, there was a political will, and in 2006 another competition for designing the square was announced. In 2008 they published the winner and it was OÜ Alver Trummal Arhitektid who had evolved the work that won in 1998. The purpose of the new design was to connect the different important parts around the square and make them cooperative, a new synergy-creating system.		The architectural competition to the area has been held a few times before the project that was finally built was chosen. The last competition, that ended in 1998 had given a very good project, but as there was no political will, the project was never put into practice. In 2011 Tallinn is going to be the Cultural Capital of Europe, there was a political will, and in 2006 another competition for designing the square was announced. In 2008 they published the winner and it was OÜ Alver Trummal Arhitektid who had evolved the work that won in 1998. The purpose of the new design was to connect the different important parts around the square and make them cooperative, a new synergy-creating system.

	~~Illustration: Map/diagram/sketches photos and background notes~~

	=== Analysis of use/users ===		=== Analysis of use/users ===
Line 81:		Line 73:


	~~Illustration: Map/diagram/sketches photos and background notes~~

	=== <font color=darkblue size=4>Core Question 2:</font> What is the role of landscape architecture in this project? ===		=== <font color=darkblue size=4>Core Question 2:</font> What is the role of landscape architecture in this project? ===

	The role of landscape architecture in this project is the purpose of the square and the buildings around it – the square is presenting them (the square connects two very important churches in Estonia). It is possible to describe a square with the buildings that are surrounding it or different views that open to people when they are on it. When it comes to this particular square, Vabaduse väljak, you could say that it has no definite borders as it is situated in the middle of the city, but the architects have tried to give the borders by placing lamp posts to one side and a colorful wall to the other to make the space more obvious and bring it out a bit more. In addition, there are some constructions on the square that match the environment and typology and develop it.		The role of landscape architecture in this project is the purpose of the square and the buildings around it – the square is presenting them (the square connects two very important churches in Estonia). It is possible to describe a square with the buildings that are surrounding it or different views that open to people when they are on it. When it comes to this particular square, Vabaduse väljak, you could say that it has no definite borders as it is situated in the middle of the city, but the architects have tried to give the borders by placing lamp posts to one side and a colorful wall to the other to make the space more obvious and bring it out a bit more. In addition, there are some constructions on the square that match the environment and typology and develop it.